A Critical Review of the First Compiled Dewan of Mirza Khan ‎Ansari

##plugins.themes.academic_pro.article.main##

Khan Mohammad Khialzai
Abdul Jabar Sapand

Abstract

This article evaluates the bibliographic presentation, editorial transparency, and selected reported spelling and word-division problems in the 1975 scholarly edition of Mirza Khan Ansari’s Dewan prepared by Dost Mohammad Dost Shinwari. Materials and method: The 1975 edition is treated as the primary object of documentary and textual-critical analysis; the account of its eight source witnesses is considered alongside published scholarship and manuscript catalogues. No new collation of original manuscripts was undertaken. The eight sources described for the edition comprise five manuscript witnesses and three printed sources; identifying them collectively as ‘manuscripts’ is inaccurate. The imprint 1354 corresponds to 1354 Hijri Shamsi (1975 CE), rather than 1354 AH. Other concerns include ambiguous witness labels and reported inconsistencies in word division and Pashto yeh forms; some proposed corrections remain unverified against a facsimile. Contribution: The study separates demonstrable bibliographic facts from provisional textual observations and proposes a documented, witness-based critical re-edition.

##plugins.themes.academic_pro.article.details##

How to Cite
Khialzai, K. M., & Sapand, A. J. (2026). A Critical Review of the First Compiled Dewan of Mirza Khan ‎Ansari. Nangarhar University Social Science Journal, 3(04), 61–69. https://doi.org/10.70436/nussj.v3i04.118

References

  1. Blumhardt, J. F., & MacKenzie, D. N. (1965). Catalogue ‎of Pashto manuscripts in the libraries of the ‎British Isles. Trustees of the British Museum and ‎the Commonwealth Relations Office. ‎https://digital.soas.ac.uk/content/LO/AC/00/00/6‎‎7/00001/PDF.pdf‎
  2. Dorn, B. (1847). A chrestomathy of the Pushtū or ‎Afghan language, to which is subjoined a glossary ‎in Afghan and English. Imperial Academy of ‎Sciences.‎
  3. Harvard Geoffrey Chaucer Website. (n.d.). Types of ‎editions. Harvard University. ‎https://chaucer.fas.harvard.edu/types-editions
  4. Hewadmal, Z. (1379 HS). Da Pashto adabiyato tarikh ‎‎[History of Pashto literature]. Danish Publishing ‎Association.‎
  5. Hewadmal, Z. (1389 HS). Da matn tseraney methodology ‎‎[Textual research methodology]. Amiri ‎Publishing Society.‎
  6. Kabir, E. H. (2025). A forgotten manuscript of Mirza ‎Khan Ansari’s Divan in the British Museum. ‎Pashto, 54(670), 13–27. ‎https://pashto.org.pk/index.php/path/article/view‎/509‎
  7. Khairi, M. A. (2024, July 22). Da Mirza Khan Ansari ‎‎(Diwan Hidayat al-Haqiqat) ta yawa ‎zhabpohaneza katana [A linguistic review of ‎Mirza Khan Ansari’s Dewan Hidayat al-Haqiqat]. ‎Taand. https://taand.net/?p=242992‎
  8. LingDocs. (n.d.). The five ی’s. LingDocs Pashto ‎Grammar. ‎https://grammar.lingdocs.com/writing/the-five-‎yeys/‎
  9. Luzhetskaya, N. L. (1996). Dorn, Johannes Albrecht ‎Bernhard. Encyclopaedia Iranica, 7(5), 511–513. ‎https://www.iranicaonline.org/articles/dorn/‎
  10. Macé, C., Bausi, A., den Heijer, J., Gippert, J., La Spisa, ‎P., Mengozzi, A., Moureau, S., & Sels, L. (2015). ‎Textual criticism and text editing. In A. Bausi et ‎al. (Eds.), Comparative Oriental manuscript ‎studies: An introduction (pp. 321–362). ‎Tredition. https://hdl.handle.net/2078.5/267233‎
  11. MacKenzie, D. N. (1959). A standard Pashto. Bulletin of ‎the School of Oriental and African Studies, 22(1–‎‎3), 231–235. https://www.jstor.org/stable/609426‎
  12. Shinwari, D. M. D. (1354 HS/1975). Da Mirza Khan ‎Ansari Dewan [The Dewan of Mirza Khan ‎Ansari]. Pashto Tolana (Pashto Academy).‎
  13. Shirzad, P. A., & Afghan, S. (1399 HS). Da Pashto ‎adabiyato tarikh (classica dawra) [History of ‎Pashto literature: Classical period]. Nawisa ‎Publishing Society.‎
  14. Tanselle, G. T. (1989). A rationale of textual criticism. ‎University of Pennsylvania Press. ‎https://www.jstor.org/stable/j.ctt3fhcwk
  15. TEI Consortium. (2025). TEI P5: Guidelines for ‎electronic text encoding and interchange (version ‎‎4.10.2, chap. 13, “Critical Apparatus”). ‎https://www.tei-c.org/Vault/P5/4.10.2/doc/tei-‎p5-doc/en/html/TC.html

Similar Articles

<< < 1 2 

You may also start an advanced similarity search for this article.